Umno talks about transformation but PAS is the party that concerts that into action. Umno does not even dare hold its party elections fearing that the party will be more divided.
Umno hasnt got the stomach to get rid of its old blood.
If PAS does not break-up having had its party elections, then the Umno leadership will have a tough time defending postponing its party elections.
Even Umno people will go away convinced that holding back elections is really an excuse by the Umno leadership to self-perpetuate.
Hence all the cock and bull story about disunity and such.
Meanwhile the victory of the so called Erdogan faction in PAS has got Ibrahim Ali provoked.
He reacted by saying the victors are opposition coalition chief Anwar Ibrahims voice in PAS.
Ibrahims outbursts are likely to be dismissed as the ranting of a loony bin and the eternal busybody.
By the way, this Erdogan and non-Erdogan thing is a fiction created by those who are fearful of PAS.
I dont see a change in the fundamental basis of PASs struggle with the ascension of the less-ulamak elements in PAS.
An attempt to divide
The whole of PAS body politics whether ulamak or non-ulamak remains whole and integral and is likely to reaffirm its commitment to Islamic politics.
I am sure the description of PAS as such is likely to be seen as an attempt to drive a wedge in the solidarity of PAS members.
I am more inclined to believe that such a commitment to a struggle is alien to the present generation of Umno people who have a different political culture.
Umno struggles about getting a share in the MRT project. Umno struggles to get a lion share of the UDA Pudu Jail redevelopment project. Umno fights for big businesses.
Umno figh! ts for i ncreasing electricity tariffs so that Independent Power Producers (IPPs) make more profit and prices of goods and services using energy get passed on to consumers.
For Ibrahim Ali, the eternal busybody and the pompous windbag, what happens inside PAS is of no relevance to him.
His comments are unsolicited and carry no weight at all.
Ibrahim, who borrowed the PAS shell in the last elections, will have no vehicle to go into elections this time.
If Umno allows Ibrahim to hitch a ride, there is something very wrong in Umno.
Dont underestimate PAS zeal
But what happens in PAS has much bearings on Umno. Umnos worse nightmares are now becoming real.
Mohamad Sabu (better known as Mat Sabu), has won the party deputy presidency with 420 votes.
He leads a group of leaders to counter conservatives who are said to prefer to link up with Umno.
I hesitate to refer them as progressives.
We cant underestimate their (PAS) zeal towards Islamic politics; they differ only in approach.
The suggestion that PAS wants to link up with Umno has always been a non-issue. PAS operates differently from Umno.
The voice of delegates and members weigh much more on the decisions taken by party leaders.
And PAS has the influence of its Dewan Ulamak.
That inference I think is a figment in the imagination of some people and probably a manifestation of hope for redemption from a more besieged party Umno.
It is Umno that has been harping on Malay unity which when translated actually means please save us, we want to stay in power.
No need for Umno
The reality has always been that the majority of PAS members who are Malays probably have no desire to supplant their Malay-ness by teaming up with Umno.
PAS simply does not need Umno to reaffirm and remind them that they are Malay first.
They are already Malays and can also justifiably claim, to be more Islamic in conduct and! behavio r.
The victory of non-ulamaks in so many party positions must be seen as what they really are a self-correction measure undertaken by PAS adherents to moderate its image, but never its content.
What is the typical image of PAS?
Its an Islamic party portraying the image of a spiritual and other worldly organization.
Its a party filled with wide-eyed mullahs, patrolling the streets enforcing dress code, unshaved chins and mandatory use of skull caps, hijab and so forth.
Umno on the other hand projects a temporal and secular image.
So what has PAS now become? It has become a spiritual and less other-worldly.
The later description conjuring the image of an uncompromising and harsh Taliban-esque organization bent on imposing harsh laws on the populace.
Viable alternative
By correcting itself, PAS can succeed better at making itself more relevant to society.
Why would PAS need Umno?
I think the victory of the moderates in PAS who will change the character of PAS from one party with Taliban-esque inclinations to a party of rational Islam, actually strikes fear in Umno.
Now, PAS with the new leadership line up offers a very credible and viable political leadership to the Malays.
The new line up also allays fears within the non-Muslim community who can see PAS now as a realistic political party.
This strikes Umno in two areas.
PAS can now offer an alternative to Malays and therefore will further erode Umnos already dwindling monopoly over Malay votes.
Secondly, it can appeal to non-Muslims who are tired of Umnos bully tactics and its cowardly support of Perkasas Malay agenda.
The trio who won the vice-presidential posts are well known non-conservative Islamists.
They are incumbent Salahuddin Ayub who took top spot with 753 votes.
Kelantan senior councillor Husam Musa was second with 660 votes while another incumbent Mahfuz Omar kept his post with 616 votes. Both Salahud! din and Mahfuz were incumbents.
Only one aim
More than two-thirds of the 18 places in the central working committee were also taken by the professionals, who were among the 53 candidates contesting the seats.
The new central working committee are Anak chairman Mazlan Aliman who received the most votes with 804 followed by Dr Hatta Ramli (765), Kamaruddin Jaafar (739), PAS lawyer Hanipa Maidin (735), Kedah Mentri Besar Azizan Abdul Razak (721), Kuala Selangor MP Dr Dzulkefly Ahmad (702),Parit Buntar MP Dr Mujahid Yusof Rawa (651), Shah Alam MP Khalid Samad (643), Abdul Ghani Shamsuddin (579), Amiruddin Hamzah (576), Kuala Terengganu MP Abdul Wahid Endut (556), Abu Bakar Chik (527), Kelantan exco member Mohd Amar Abdullah (470), Johors Dr Mahfodz Mohamed (449), Kota Raja MP and Muslimat deputy chief Dr Siti Mariah Mahmud (445), Selangor PAS commissioner Dr Hasan Ali (437), Abdul Ghani Abdul Rahman (430) and former Muslimat chief Nuridah Salleh (416).
It simply means, PAS has succeeded in the area where Umno has failed.
Umno leadership talks about pompous transformation of this and that but it is PAS which is actualy walking the talk.
What of the future?
PAS can now play the role of a kingmaker determining who leads the next government.
Despite the victory of more than 12 moderates in the leadership line-up, PAS lacks a figure with a stature credible enough to muster sufficient national support from all quarters.
If it can find such a leader to lend its support, PAS can deliver the support of conservative Malays to the general desire of the people to punish Umno.
I predict they will do so because PAS has only one aim. To topple Umno in the next elections.
The writer is a former Umno state rep. This is an excerpt of his latest blog entry at Sakmongkol 47. He is also an FMT columnist.